Pearsanta abandons High Court challenge over Noel Smyth's Alburn CMBS

By James Wallace - Wednesday, September 26, 2012 15:45

Pearsanta, the special purpose vehicle established by Vincent Barratt, has abandoned the High Court challenge against N M Rothschild & Sons and US Bank Trustees Limited over the appointment of Solutus Advisors as special servicer on the defaulted Alburn Real Estate Capital CMBS.

Barratt’s Pearsanta initiated High Court proceedings against Rothschild and US Bank Trustees on 22 June, as revealed first by CoStar News on 26 June, to seek a judgement to ratify Solutus’ appointment under the securitisation’s documentation.

After complying with the Court’s decree and making the first of two advance payments to cover potential costs due to the joint defendants, Pearsanta declined to make the instalments by the 28 August 2012. 

Instead, Pearsanta has agreed to a settlement with Rothschild and US Bank Trustees in respect of, inter alia, waiving the right to appoint a special servicer and paying a proportion of the defendants’ costs.

Pearsanta’s withdrawal from the legal challenge is thought to be as a result of both judges’ view that an expedited hearing – required by Pearsanta to influence the asset management and disposal strategy of the 45-strong UK secondary portfolio – would not be granted.

In the case management hearing on 31 July, the second of the two hearings, the Judge revealed that Pearsanta paid around £100,000 to buy the “out of the money” £11.7m nominally-valued junior loan from The Co-Operative Bank.

Given that an expedited hearing was ruled out, even if Pearsanta was successful in obtaining a High Court judgement to ratify the appointment of Solutus Advisors, a significant proportion of the 45 assets would, in all likelihood, have been sold by the date of the verdict.

The very best case scenario, therefore, was a hollow victory for Pearsanta, which is why the settlement is thought to have been agreed.

Noel Smyth’s Alburn Real Estate has signed a separate settlement and has agreed, among other things, to co-operate fully with the on-going enforcement and disposal process.

Running concurrent to Rothschild’s own defence preparation, significant work has been undertaken to prepare a portfolio sale of the around two-thirds of the Alburn portfolio by value, which Savills will bring to market within the next two to three weeks.

The balance of the portfolio will be sold piecemeal by Savills, for UK and Wales properties, and Moorfields Corporate Recovery in Scotland.

Two very small assets have already been sold.

At the time of the enforcement article back in mid-May, CoStar News published the portfolio make-up at the time including CBRE’s April 2012 valuation of each asset, which can be seen here.

Get in Touch
+44 203 205 4600